Atlas Financial Holdings, Inc. Enters Into Agreement with American Financial Group, Inc.; Continues Strategic Evaluation

Atlas Financial Holdings, Inc. (NASDAQ:AFH) (“Atlas” or the “Company”) announced today that as an initial outcome of its strategic review, Atlas concluded that the utilization of its wholly owned Managing General Agency (“MGA”) operation to work with strategic external insurance and reinsurance partners will enable the Company to leverage its focus, experience and infrastructure to create value for stakeholders.

A definitive agreement was executed effective June 10, 2019 between Atlas and American Financial Group, Inc. (NYSE:AFG). Under this agreement Atlas will act as an underwriting manager for AFG’s National Interstate (“NATL”) subsidiary and transition new and renewal paratransit business to NATL paper for this book of business. This strategic arrangement will combine Atlas’ niche platform including the analytics and technology Atlas has developed based on decades of expertise and data in this specialized area of commercial automobile insurance with AFG and NATL’s strong financial position and disciplined underwriting focus. Starting in July 2019, Atlas’ wholly owned insurance subsidiaries will cease writing new paratransit business and begin writing both new business and transitioning the existing paratransit business to the underwriting management arrangement with NATL. Sandler O'Neill + Partners, L.P. advised the Company on this transaction.

Under the agreement, AFG has certain rights including a warrant to acquire 19.9% of the outstanding AFH common stock for $0.69 per share and an option to purchase the renewal rights owned by the Company in the future. This program will continue to focus on small fleet operations in this unique and important niche market. In 2018, paratransit business represented approximately $110 million of the Company’s gross written premium. The Company estimates that the majority of this business will be eligible for quotation over the first twelve month of this arrangement.

Scott D. Wollney, Atlas’ President & CEO said “We are excited to partner with American Financial Group and National Interstate to transition this business in a strategic approach that we expect to benefit both companies. Continuing to provide our distribution partners and policyholders with the specialized customer-centric value proposition they expect from Atlas in partnership with one of the largest commercial auto focused companies in the country at a time when the market is hard is extremely valuable to all involved.”